Get Mobile App

Special Announcement: Introducing our New Customer Care Center

Manage your account, your contact information, view your policy numbers, PDF documents and more


You will need to use your email address on file with Conner Insurance Agency to access your information, A link then will be emailed back to you.

Be sure to check your inbox, junk folders, and/or trash bin for this link.


Try it now! Click here to receive your LOG-IN LINK


Note: For security purposes, you will be asked to enter your last name and zip code before accessing your information.

Please feel free to call 740-654-2848 or reply to this email with any questions.




ASK About our Private Flood Insurance: Reduced Rates & Better Coverage



The Conner Insurance Agency is built on a foundation of integrity, ethics, and professionalism. The agency is dedicated to customer service, offering our clients the advantage of unparalleled product knowledge and fully customized insurance packages.


With dozens of other insurance agencies in the local area, customers will appreciate the level of service and respect the Conner Insurance Agency provides. Our clients will see the unique value of always having their best interest placed first in our agency.


We hope they also recognize our commitment to helping our community grow and improve through our involvement in local projects and volunteer programs.


Call for an appointment today or drop in and say "Hello"!

Welcome to Fairfield County's leading Insurance Provider, Conner Insurance Agency in Lancaster, Ohio.


The Conner Insurance Agency, is a local business, owned and operated by Lancaster native, Shirley Conner. She is committed to serving her client-base – friends and new customers alike – with integrity and honesty, focusing on what each individual client needs


This agency offers a host of insurance products to protect both personal and professional assets, including homes, vehicles and businesses. Some of the insurance options available protect Service Garages, Barber/Beauty Shops, Contractors, and Professional Offices. Please contact the office for a full list of services.


With more than 20 years of customer service and sales experience, Shirley will strive to understand exactly what her clients’ needs are and provide a tailored insurance package to fit their requirements.


Tailoring my products to the specific needs of my clients will allow me establish a first rate agency based on superior customer service, professionalism, integrity and honesty. In putting the needs of my clients first, I will be seen as an agent who can be trusted to stay focused on the client and their best interest. To ensure that those needs are met I will set up a review program for all current clients and conduct the same review for all new clients, so we can determine any gaps they may have in their coverage or any coverage they currently have that is not needed.


I am the owner of Conner Insurance Agency and as such in the business of making sure that my clients personal and commercial assets are protected for now and in the future. My goal as a business owner and insurance agent is to provide my clients with the most appropriate services and coverage at a competitive rate.




Check out our new Mobile App and be sure to share our app with your friends and neighbors!

Shirley Conner